Thursday, July 26, 2007

School Holidays?

I recently went on holiday. Well that was meant to be the idea. No sooner had I left Hong Kong than I was phoned about one of the Schools of which I am the Supervisor. Since then I have been on the phone constantly and, if not the phone, then email. For legal reasons, I have to be careful what I say even here. However, this report from the agency WE reported the case to and one of the press reports about it will give you the idea. They are both substantially correct.

ICAC Press Release

21/07/07

Primary school teacher caught red-handed by ICAC for alleged bribery

A teacher of a primary school, who is also involved in admission procedures, was caught red-handed by the ICAC yesterday (Friday) after she took a bribe of $70,000 from a parent, allegedly for facilitating the admission of the latter's daughter to the school.

The ICAC commenced an investigation after receiving a corruption report.

Inquiries revealed that the teacher had allegedly solicited $30,000 from the parent, claiming that it would strengthen his daughter's application for enrolment to the school.

Upon the teacher's solicitation, the parent had already made a cash payment of $30,000 to her on Wednesday (July 18).

Investigation also revealed that the teacher had allegedly further solicited $70,000 from the parent for the same reason.

An ambush operation was mounted by ICAC officers yesterday inside a restaurant in a shopping mall in Kowloon Tong. The teacher was arrested after taking the $70,000 "bait money" from the parent.

Subsequent ICAC investigation revealed that the teacher had allegedly approached three other parents and solicited advantages from them, claiming that she could provide assistance in admitting their children to the school.

ICAC inquiries showed that two of those parents had allegedly paid the teacher $20,000 and $580,000 respectively.

The management of the primary school concerned has rendered full assistance in the investigation.

An ICAC spokesman reminds that parents should be cautious when seeking to enroll their children in schools of their preference.

"Should parents come across solicitation of advantages for admission, they should come forward to report to the ICAC.

"Information will be treated in the strictest confidence," the spokesman says.

Press Report



(Click on the above to enlarge)


Once this story broke everything went completely mad. The press and TV camped outside the School, even though it is the summer vacation, and I received many requests for information, even though the matter is subject to legal proceedings. It is a real temptation to think you must react and do something. Plenty of people are clamouring for you to do just that.

It is hard to see the wood from the trees at times. In fact, it is all very simple really. A teacher has been arrested, allegedly for taking money to facilitate the entrance of children into the School. If guilty, she will be punished; if not, she will be acquitted. It is not for us or anyone else to pre-judge the legal process and there is nothing for us to say or do with respect to the case in question except to co-operate with the legal authorities.

There is, of course, plenty to do in terms of managing the fall-out from the case, but nothing much to do about the case itself. Convincing some people of this takes quite some time!

What, however, the case does raise is the question I keep raising and have discussed here, namely the culture around our Christian schools. Leaving this case aside for one moment, the only reason people are tempted to take bribes is because parents are willing to pay them and because we in the Church have cultivated a culture of social elitism. A Christian response I would suggest is, of course, to expose corruption, but it is also to challenge the culture which makes it possible.

This may mean Christian schools having to cater more in future for the poor than for the rich.

Anyway, the story is going to run and run whether I am on holiday or not. I will keep you informed as it develops and as much as I am able.

Please pray that I may have the wisdom I need to handle it properly.

Sunday, July 15, 2007

Summer

Well tonight I start a holiday. I can't remember feeling so much in need of one. I am truly exhausted. It has been a massive struggle finding cover for my services here while I am away and as always it is the busy people who are willing to help. I am extremely grateful to them. The end of the summer is always challenging, this year even more so, but now I am looking forward to a change of scenery and time spent with family. I will keep in touch as long as my internet access allows!

If you are planning a trip yourself, I hope it is a safe and happy one!

Friday, July 06, 2007

Where I am Now: 3. Liturgy and the Eucharist - Part Two

I did think that I wouldn't have a lot to say in this post having said most of it previously! However, I discover I have more to say than I thought!

It is the end of term here and I have loads of services and other school events to lead and attend. I was invited to two more today, I am afraid enough is enough! We are looking forward to our holiday which is creeping up at the moment. I hope to have more blogs posted before then though.

Have a good weekend!

Where I am Now: 3. Liturgy and the Eucharist - Part Two

When I became a Christian, and for many years afterwards, the Eucharist did not feature very highly in my life. My background was such that other aspects of worship were much more important. Even at St Andrew’s, the first Anglican Church I went to, the Eucharist was not a central part of church life or mine. At London Bible College, I started to think more seriously about it and, as I have mentioned previously, I came to see it as important.

I was, however, very much on the Protestant end of the spectrum in understanding its significance, not believing that anything particular happened in it. It was a memorial meal, that and nothing more. It was really only when I went to Banchory and was celebrating the Eucharist regularly as well as trying to bring some renewal in our services that I found myself thinking more seriously about what it actually meant.

A major consideration for me was Church history and tradition. The Eucharist has been at the heart of the Church’s worship in much the same form since at least the second century. It was sidelined as a consequence of the reformation in many Protestant churches. Protestants often played it off against the Bible and preaching and were highly critical of the Roman Mass. Calvin, one of the leading reformers, while critical of the Roman Mass, believed that the Lord’s Supper should be at the heart of the Church’s life and worship. An aspect of his teaching that most of his followers ignored!

Indeed, Calvin, in his belief and teaching that Communion should be offered to believers weekly, was ahead of most people at the time, Catholic or Protestant. At the beginning of the sixteenth century, people took communion very infrequently, often no more than annually. Calvin not only believed in frequent Communion, he also had a high view of what was happening in the Eucharist. He certainly did not believe in transubstantiation, the doctrine that the bread and wine actually become the body and blood of Christ, but nor did he see the Lord’s Supper as a memorial meal and no more. For Calvin, there was a real partaking of Christ in the Supper, but spiritually and by faith. Calvin’s negative comments about the Mass, as it was celebrated and understood in his own day, have perhaps meant that people have missed the emphasis that he actually does put on the importance of the sacrament.

I also think that Protestants today forget that the Roman Catholic Church of the present is not the Church that Calvin criticised. Roman Catholicism has changed and has perhaps come to express its teaching in a less crude way than was the case. I, personally, differ somewhat in my own understanding to the official Catholic teaching, but reading the Catechism of the Catholic Church on the Eucharist again just now, I am struck by how reasonable and balanced it is, and how much I find myself in agreement with it. Now the way it is expressed is somewhat different to how I would put it. And there are things I am not exactly comfortable with such as the veneration of the host outside of the Eucharist and the belief that the Eucharist has benefits for the dead, but in its treatment of the Mass as a sacrifice, which has traditionally been a problem for Protestants, the catechism is very cautious in how it expresses itself.

For example, let me quote in full paragraphs 1365 and 1366:

1365 Because it is the memorial of Christ's Passover, the Eucharist is also a sacrifice. The sacrificial character of the Eucharist is manifested in the very words of institution: ‘This is my body which is given for you’ and ‘This cup which is poured out for you is the New Covenant in my blood.’ In the Eucharist Christ gives us the very body which he gave up for us on the cross, the very blood which he ‘poured out for many for the forgiveness of sins.’

1366 The Eucharist is thus a sacrifice because it re-presents (makes present) the sacrifice of the cross, because it is its memorial and because it applies its fruit:

[Christ], our Lord and God, was once and for all to offer himself to God the Father by his death on the altar of the cross, to accomplish there an everlasting redemption. But because his priesthood was not to end with his death, at the Last Supper ‘on the night when he was betrayed,’ [he wanted] to leave to his beloved spouse the Church a visible sacrifice (as the nature of man demands) by which the bloody sacrifice which he was to accomplish once for all on the cross would be re-presented, its memory perpetuated until the end of the world, and its salutary power be applied to the forgiveness of the sins we daily commit.

This last paragraph is a quote from the Council of Trent of 1562 in which the Roman Catholic Church first attempted to respond to the Reformation.

The language in these two paragraphs isn’t language Protestants would use, but is it really so objectionable? The word ‘transubstantiation’, so hated by Protestants, is only used once. I am not trying to defend Roman Catholicism just to point out that many are reacting to a Roman Catholicism that no longer exists, if ever it did.

Roman Catholics believe that Jesus is ‘truly, really and substantially’ present in the Eucharist. Having also read Calvin again on this before writing this blog, I am sure he would agree. The issue between Calvin and the Roman understanding would seem to be not whether, but how? On a personal level, this remains the difference between my own understanding and Roman teaching. For the Roman Catholicism of the catechism teaches that Christ is physically present. For Calvin, he is spiritually present.

My problem with Roman Catholic teaching is that I cannot for the life of me see how physically eating Christ can be of any spiritual benefit. The RC catechism itself says that we are spiritually fed in the Eucharist, but if we are spiritually fed what use is Christ’s physical flesh? Chewing on Christ while he was alive on earth, if I can express it crudely, would have had no benefit whatsoever. Why would it make any difference now?

And yet given that the RC position is that in the Eucharist we spiritually feed on Christ, does it matter that some may believe he is physically present? It’s not something to fall out over surely? And not something that we ought to allow to divide us. What I am trying to say is that I think Calvin got it right, but that the present RC position is nearer to Calvin than that of many who call themselves Calvinists! Having quoted the RC catechism let me quote Calvin. He is talking about how Christ is present in the Supper:

‘Now, if anyone should ask me how this takes place, I shall not be ashamed to confess that it is a secret too lofty for either my mind to comprehend or my words to declare. And, to speak more plainly, I rather experience than understand it. Therefore, I here embrace without controversy the truth of God in which I may safely rest. He declares his flesh the food of my soul, his blood its drink [John 6:53ff.]. I offer my soul to him to be fed with such food. In his Sacred Supper he bids me take, eat, and drink his body and blood under the symbols of bread and wine. I do not doubt that he himself truly presents them, and that I receive them.’ (Institutes, Book IV, CH. XVII, paragraph 32)

This is the best one paragraph statement of the meaning of the Lord’s Supper I know. And while I am quoting Calvin, let me quote another helpful paragraph from him. Having criticized what he sees as a misunderstanding of the Supper, he writes:

‘But when these absurdities have been set aside, I freely accept whatever can be made to express the true and substantial partaking of the body and blood of the Lord, which is shown to believers under the sacred symbols of the Supper-and so to express it that they may be understood not to receive it solely by imagination or understanding of mind, but to enjoy the thing itself as nourishment of eternal life.’ (Institutes, Book IV, CH. XVII, paragraph 19)

Anyway, this was the understanding I came to at Banchory. Furthermore, I came to believe that the problem of the Anglican Book of Common Prayer wasn’t that it was too traditional; the common accusation against the Prayer Book, but that it was not traditional enough. The Book of Common Prayer while expressing a Calvinist approach to the Eucharist was moving liturgically away from the tradition and practice of the Church. It was prevented from moving further by the death of Edward VI and the eventual coming to the throne of Elizabeth I, which rather froze things where they were. This was how basically they stayed in Anglicanism until comparatively recently. The liturgy we use here at Christ Church, derived from what is known as Common Worship, I believe expresses a Calvinist understanding of the Eucharist while remaining in liturgical continuity with the great liturgies of the Church of the past. There is, I hope, nothing in it that a Roman Catholic would find offensive.

Would Calvin like it? I suspect not. However, not because he would object to it theologically, but because, I suspect, he was more austere in his approach to worship. Would he ‘freely accept’ it as expressing the ‘true and substantial partaking of the body and blood of the Lord’ he also believed in? I hope so and would like to think so. I think he, like me, would be appalled at how lightly believers value the Sacred Supper and how casual they have become towards it.

Tuesday, July 03, 2007

Where I am Now: 3. Liturgy and the Eucharist – Part One

Thank you to those who sent good wishes on the occasion of the 25th anniversary of my ordination as a priest. I really, really appreciate your messages.

Today I post Part One of the third blog about where I am now. I was ordained just after the Alternative Service Book (ASB) had been published initiating a time of great liturgical change in the Church of England. As I began to write about the Eucharist, I realized that I couldn't let the process of liturgical change go without comment. My apologies to those who think that liturgy is a thing of the 'world and the flesh', if not of the devil. In Part Two, I intend to write more about the Eucharist itself.

Where I am now: 3. Liturgy and the Eucharist - Part One

Services when I first went to them were not Eucharistic. In the Anglican Church, they were mainly Mattins and Evensong and in other traditional Churches a mixture of hymns readings and prayers with a sermon thrown in. In the House Churches, services were much more exciting with just about everything happening - except Communion. Communion did, of course, happen at times in all these different Churches, but it was very much peripheral and easily missed. In none of the Churches I personally attended did the idea that you needed a priest before you could have worship make any sense at all. We believed in the priesthood of all believers.

It was while at London Bible College that I became convinced through Bible Study of the centrality and importance of the Eucharist. (I am using the word Eucharist as the most neutral of the available terms.) It seemed clear to me from 1 Corinthians 11 that what Paul refers to as the Lord’s Supper was frequent and central.

This was also the time of liturgical revision in the Church of England. Liturgical revision sought to translate the Church of England services into English. Well, from an English that no-one used to one that at least they could understand. It also placed far more emphasis on the Eucharist. In many Anglican Churches, this was a time when they switched to making the Eucharist the main service of the day on Sundays. I was very happy with this and still am.

One of the problems with liturgical reform in the Church of England, of course, was that it has always had people who believe different things about the Eucharist and about what is happening in it. This undoubtedly made liturgical reform harder. In the Roman Catholic Church, liturgical reform was more radical and more easily accomplished. In the Church of England, however, there was much resistance to change.

This said, however, much of the resistance to change had nothing to do with theology. People had developed a sentimental attachment to the Book of Common Prayer and to its archaic English. Attempts, normally initiated by the clergy, to change to a modern English service, which was often in every other way the same as the old service, were met with passionate resistance. The bandwagon against change was often joined by people who hardly ever attended Church, but who liked to think of it as a sort of religious museum preserving the traditions of the past to be viewed at will.

The attempt to change to a Eucharist rather than a Morning Prayer service for the main service of the day was more interesting, though no less divisive. The reason for the problems is interesting and instructive. For many, it was one thing to substitute an archaic language Morning Prayer service with an archaic language Communion service, but something altogether different to substitute an archaic language Morning Prayer with a modern language Eucharist. What mattered was keeping the language, the old language. Many churches were severely divided and damaged by the whole business of liturgical change.

Ironically, while those responsible, at Synod level, for re-writing the services may have cared about liturgy and theology most people who entered the battle in the Churches rarely cared about theology. It was all about language whether it was to be old or modern. It is a further irony that the reason for change often given by the clergy instituting it was that it was to aid mission, making our services more accessible to outsiders, and yet the process of change used so much energy that there was often little time left for mission or for anything else. Some of the arguments were very bitter indeed and some of the divisions went very deep.

There are still some pockets of resistance, but the modern language debate has largely been won by the modernisers. Concessions have been made and the old services are still used, but not normally as the main service of the day. You have to go at a different time of day or on a different day altogether if you want the old language and services. A significant number of Churches have made a modern language Eucharist the main service. How has this affected mission? Not in the slightest. Fewer people now attend the Church of England, for example, than ever. Does this mean that liturgical reform should not have been undertaken? Yes and no. It illustrates I think the danger of imposing liturgy on people politically without a concern for theology and for the reason why we are doing it. All too often the reason for change seemed to be fashion and trendiness. Nevertheless, liturgical reform was needed, I believe, not in the first place because of language, but because of the need to put the Eucharist at the heart of the Church’s worship and because of the inadequacy of the Eucharistic liturgy of the Book of Common Prayer.

This is a long and complicated subject and it has been much written about. I won’t repeat it all here! The Communion service in the 1662 Prayer Book was a much emasculated service coming as it did out the debates about the meaning of Communion arising from the time of the reformation in the sixteenth century. Much was a reaction to and rejection of the Roman Catholic Mass. I felt that the attempt by those responsible for producing the new Eucharistic liturgies to go behind the controversies of the reformation and learn from the liturgy of the early Church was right. I also liked the fact that the resulting service was very similar to the modern Roman Catholic service. I liked it, not because it was modern, but because it restored what had been lost and gave us a fuller more complete service that brought us closer together.

I could live with the new Eucharistic liturgy in archaic English even if I preferred it in modern English, simply because it was a better service with a fuller understanding of the meaning of the Eucharist. I used to say that ideally we would have a Latin version given that this is the language underlying many of the texts we use in the service. I am mildly surprised to see that many Roman Catholics now feel the same and there is a return to the Latin Mass in some churches. Those with good memories will remember my own attempt to make use of the Latin Mass.

To those who say that Latin is a dead language that is irrelevant in the age we live, all I would say is that the Funeral Mass for Pope John Paul seemed to be very relevant and powerful. It was also in Latin. The loss of Latin at the reformation in the Protestant Churches and the subsequent near loss in the Roman Catholic Churches after Vatican II has meant that those in liturgically based churches have lost a common language that could have been a symbol of our unity worldwide. Of course, people must also worship in a language they understand, but you don’t need to be a classicist to know that ‘Gloria in excelsis Deo’ means ‘Glory to God in the highest’! But I digress.

The process of liturgical reform in the 1970s and 1980s at least gave us a Eucharistic liturgy that put the Eucharist at the heart of the Church’s worship and which brought the Roman Catholic and Anglican Churches closer together in their official liturgies. I am less happy with the ‘pick and mix’ approach of more recent liturgical change, where liturgy is seen as a menu of texts that you choose from and put together locally as you see fit, but that is another matter. The Eucharist is still very much at the heart of the Church.

Now I realize that for those brought up in more charismatically inclined Churches or in non-conformist Churches all this sounds like another language in and of itself. Worship should be Spirit led and spontaneous not written and fixed. Well I wouldn’t want to exclude that. It is interesting, though, how quickly spontaneity takes a fixed form. We all have a liturgy of sorts consciously or unconsciously. What I think is a very fair criticism of liturgically based Churches is that the liturgy can become an end in and of itself and its purpose, to enable us to worship God together, forgotten.

Wednesday, June 27, 2007

Disappointed: A Retrospective Twent-five Years On

Today I celebrate twenty-five years as a priest. While, sadly, I am not exactly doing anything to celebrate, I am publishing today the text of the sermon I intend to preach on Sunday to mark the occasion. Readers of this blog, epsecially new ones, may like to read it in the context of the Personal Journey Series.

Disappointed: A Retrospective Twenty-five Years On

Twenty-six years ago this week, I was ordained a deacon in the Church of England. A year later, twenty-five years ago, on June 27, I was ordained a priest in the Cathedral Church of Jesus Christ and the Blessed Virgin Mary in Chester. It is customary to celebrate becoming a priest rather than becoming a deacon, and so today, on the nearest Sunday, I celebrate 25 years as priest.

Since ordination, I have served a curacy in an urban setting on Merseyside in the north of England; I have worked as Chaplain and Tutor in Religious Studies at a secular college in the south of England; and as the Rector of two churches in a semi-rural and rural setting in the north of Scotland. And, of course, for the past seven years, I have had the privilege of being the Vicar of Christ Church, here in Hong Kong.

Twenty-five years is a milestone of sorts, and I have recently been reflecting on my ministry: what I have learnt and what has changed, both in my own perceptions, attitudes, and beliefs and in the Church and the world around me. I hope today you will allow me, for the sermon, to reflect a little bit on how I feel. There’s not enough time to say all I would like to say so what follows will, inevitably, be highly selective and runs the risk of being misleading because of that. For a fuller reflection, I must ask you to look elsewhere! Having issued this disclaimer, let me begin.

I have been thinking about this sermon for some while and about what word or phrase would best describe my feelings as I look back. I am both surprised and saddened that the word I keep coming back to is ‘disappointed’. Now let me say again that there is much more that I would want to say. I am, for example, genuinely grateful to all who have supported me both in the years leading up to ordination and in ministry since. I am today especially grateful to those who believed in me when I first told them I felt called to the ministry. This for me was around the age of 13. I give thanks to God for those who were prepared to stick by me and give me the help and encouragement I needed.

It was 1974 when, at the age of 19, I went to theological college to study for my first degree in theology. It was with tremendous optimism that I embarked on this adventure. Winnie will tell you that, while not a thoroughgoing pessimist, I am not by nature optimistic. I was, however, part of a group of people who really believed that God was wanting to do something new in the Church and the world and that he was calling us to be part of it.

I had been much affected by the Charismatic Movement and what were described at the time as the House Churches. Although people had turned from God and, as a result, the Church was witnessing sharp decline, we believed all this was about to change. God was going to renew his Church and bring many back to Him. Yes, there was much that was wrong, but through the power of the Holy Spirit it could be different.

‘For freedom Christ has set us free. Stand firm, therefore, and do not submit again to a yoke of slavery’. (Galatians 5:1) The opening of our second reading for this morning.

This was a verse that resonated with us in those days. In the UK, as in many parts of the world, society was witnessing massive social change. The word freedom seemed to catch the mood. Politically, countries sought freedom from their colonial past, from apartheid, or Stalinist domination. Economically, people wanted freedom from capitalist oppression or Marxist failure, depending on your political bent. Socially, people wanted freedom from what they regarded as the oppressive institutions of the past. Sexually, women demanded freedom from patriarchy and the chance to be treated equally; homosexuals hadn’t become gay yet and campaigned for freedom from bigotry; men and women of all sexual orientations struggled for freedom from traditional forms of morality. Popular culture was all about obtaining freedom from old-fashioned standards of right and wrong.

We wanted freedom, too. We believed that freedom could only be found in Christ. The Church had lost that freedom and needed to rediscover it. Freedom from church tradition that was no longer relevant to a changing world. Freedom to worship and serve God in the new life of the Spirit. Freedom from all that oppresses and enslaves us. It was a very exciting time. A time when it seemed renewal and change were possible. A chance for a renewed Church to proclaim the Gospel to a fast-changing world.

What went wrong? Well, my charismatic friends probably wouldn’t agree with me, but the promised renewal just did not happen and the Charismatic Movement itself became introspective and focused on superficial experiences. Individuals were often affected positively by it, but the Church on the whole was not.

The low point for me in all this came many years later with the so-called Toronto Blessing, named after a Church in Toronto where it was first experienced. People received the ‘blessing’ at meetings where they passed out and had a variety of experiences, including hysterical laughter and making animal noises such as barking like a dog. In 1974, there was quite a lot of opposition to the Church. It was something that people rebelled against. By 1994, when the Toronto Blessing first came on the scene, those outside the Church had largely lost interest in anything to do with the Church. Is it any wonder? Others will disagree with me, but I regard this as the point at which the Charismatic Movement ceased to have anything positive to offer the Church.

It’s a shame because the traditional Churches did need spiritual renewal if they were to meet the challenge of the age. Instead, the traditional Churches, despite all their rhetoric to the contrary, turned in on themselves too and concentrated on political and liturgical reform. Instead of working out how we could win a lost world for Christ, we spent countless hours on internal discussions and disputes. I dread to think how much of my own ministry has been spent discussing which particular liturgy we should or should not use. We talked a lot about mission, and how we talked, but how little we actually engaged in it. I am not sure we even know what it is any more.

So now, after 25 years as a priest, the Church I was ordained in is tearing itself to bits, not over its doctrine of God, or its understanding of the person of Christ, or over the question of how a person receives salvation – disputes from the past – but over sex. While the Charismatics have been lying on the floor unconscious and while the liberals and traditionalists have been arguing over whether being gay prevents you from being a priest, the world has just moved on. The world doesn’t bother us very much, because there is not much to be bothered about.

Intellectually in the universities, in the media, and in popular culture in general, Christianity is simply irrelevant. There are places in the world where the Church can still make a political impression, but in the world of ideas, the Christian faith is not seen as having anything meaningful to contribute. Christianity is meaningless to the vast majority of people.

Instead of Christianity influencing the way people think in the world, within the Church itself many Christians have simply adopted the values and ideas of the world around them. Let me, very briefly, give as examples three areas where I think this especially true:

1. Atheism: While most people are not strictly atheists, Richard Dawkins, notwithstanding, they may as well be for all the difference God makes to them. Just as God has become largely irrelevant to the lives of many people outside the Church, so too he has become irrelevant to the lives of many people inside the Church. It’s not that people do not believe in God and not that they don’t value their time spent in Church, they do. It’s just that they are not particularly interested in God the rest of the time. Many Christians are practical atheists, their belief in God is merely a theoretical one: intellectually they believe there probably is a God, but practically this belief has very little affect on how they live their life and the decisions they make concerning it.

2. Consumerism: As communism has died as a force in our world, consumerism has taken over. It is a dominant influence in most Churches, too. As a ‘what’s in it for me’ philosophy has come to dominate in society so it dominates what happens in the Church. What makes me happy. What I want. Or as a poster I know puts it, ‘It’s all about me’. We expect our clergy to take this on board when leading services, preaching, or organising church activities and meetings. No matter that Jesus calls us to follow Him regardless of personal cost to ourselves, even leaving the ‘dead to bury the dead’ (as in this morning’s Gospel). No matter that Jesus said that it is only when we lose our lives that we will save them. And no matter that he said we must deny ourselves: the complete opposite of consumerism.

3. Entertainment: We have become an entertainment based culture. People expect to be entertained and for everything to be entertaining. That’s understood by the entertainment providers, hence the huge TVs, the DVDs, CDs, the ipod, the mobile, the internet, non-stop TV, constant celebrity gossip, and with even the news made to seem like a television soap. We expect death and disaster to be fun to watch as we enjoy our TV dinners. And Christians want Church to be entertaining too. Often it is not, hence the low priority many give to Bible Studies and sermons. Some Churches have understood this and embraced it, and going to Church has become more like going to a show. Priests have become performers. We have forgotten that when we go to Church, we go to a service. An opportunity to serve both God and those we go to Church with, and not to be entertained.

All this is bad news for me believing as I still do that God called me first and foremost to preach and teach. I believe my role, as a priest, is precisely to help people apply their faith to and in their daily lives; that the worship I lead is not for our benefit and what we get out of it, but for God and what he thinks of it; that Church is where we go to grow spiritually and to learn more about God, irrespective of whether it is entertaining or not. But as someone very honestly said to me recently, ‘Ross on Sundays most people don’t understand what you are saying and don’t want to’

‘For freedom Christ has set us free’, but we have submitted again to a yoke of slavery as we have allowed ourselves to be possessed by the spirits of the age. Spirits that tell us that God is not relevant to how we live our lives, that what matters most is ourselves and what we want, and that we have a right to be constantly entertained, even when we come to Church.

So I am disappointed. Disappointed at missed opportunities. Disappointed at our own complicity as Christians in society’s rejection of Christian values and beliefs. Disappointed that we have failed so miserably to make an impact on the world for whom Christ died. Disappointed for all the people who have missed out on the Gospel because of it. And I am disappointed in myself for not having been more effective as a priest and preacher and in my own personal failure to make a difference.

Let me stop there before you all decide that I badly need a holiday. But in closing, let me say that I am not disappointed that I became a priest. I believe there is no greater calling, no work so important, and no sacrifice not worth making. I am grateful to God that despite my own failings and the times I have undoubtedly let Him down that he has not let me down, but instead continues to allow me to serve Him as a priest.

It is my prayer, at this milestone in my ministry, that if He allows, that in 25, or however many years time, I may look back and feel less disappointed than I do now. For I remain convinced that if we are willing to accept the freedom that Christ has given and refuse to be enslaved by the world around us that we can be agents of liberation for people whose lives are trapped in sin and despair.

I am not confident or optimistic that this will happen, but I am hopeful.

Saturday, June 16, 2007

Saturday

It's been a very demanding week. I have spent a lot of time interviewing for teachers at two of the Schools I am involved in. I always find this demanding: having to make decisions that affect a lot of lives on the basis of a 30 minute to an hour interview. At one School, the choice was reasonably straightforward; at the other, not nearly so.

I am working on my next post, which is on the Eucharist. I hope it will be ready for Monday!

Have a good weekend.

Thursday, June 14, 2007

Corpus Christi

The following is a sermon I preached for Corpus Christi this year. As I am about to write on the Eucharist in my series on my spiritual journey, I thought it might be useful to post it. It can also be heard on my Church's website.

Corpus Christi

Readings:

"For I received from the Lord what I also handed on to you, that the Lord Jesus on the night when he was betrayed took a loaf of bread, and when he had given thanks, he broke it and said, "This is my body that is for you. Do this in remembrance of me." In the same way he took the cup also, after supper, saying, "This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink it, in remembrance of me." For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes." (1 Corinthians 11:23-26 NRSV)

"I am the living bread that came down from heaven. Whoever eats of this bread will live forever; and the bread that I will give for the life of the world is my flesh." The Jews then disputed among themselves, saying, "How can this man give us his flesh to eat?" So Jesus said to them, "Very truly, I tell you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you. Those who eat my flesh and drink my blood have eternal life, and I will raise them up on the last day; for my flesh is true food and my blood is true drink. Those who eat my flesh and drink my blood abide in me, and I in them. Just as the living Father sent me, and I live because of the Father, so whoever eats me will live because of me. This is the bread that came down from heaven, not like that which your ancestors ate, and they died. But the one who eats this bread will live forever."" (John 6:51-58 NRSV)


June 7 was the day known as Corpus Christi. In some parts of the world, it is a public holiday. Corpus Christi is Latin for the Body of Christ. As the Anglican lectionary puts it, it is a ‘Day of Thanksgiving for the Institution of Holy Communion’, otherwise known as the Eucharist, the Mass, the Lord’s Supper, or the Breaking of Bread. However, as these different names suggest, there are real differences between Christians as to what it means and what, if anything, happens in it.

These differences largely emerged as a result of the 16th century European Reformation. At the time of the Reformation, the Reformers were very critical of the way the Catholic Mass was celebrated. I think most, Roman Catholics included, would agree nowadays that there was some justification for theReformers concerns. It needs to be said, however, that the Mass celebrated by Roman Catholics today is very different to the Mass celebrated then and of which the Reformers were so critical. Criticisms of the practice of the Mass in the 16th century cannot simply be transferred to the Roman Catholic Mass of the present.

It was one thing for the Reformers to agree on their protest, another altogether agreeing on an alternative. There emerged sharp disagreements between the Reformers. Neither they, nor their followers, could agree on an understanding of the Eucharist. These disagreeemnets are still with us today.

At the risk of a gross over-simplification, there were and are, basically three different approaches. At one extreme, are those who see nothing happening in the elements of the Eucharist. This was the position of Zwingli and his followers. Essentially for them, the Eucharist is a chance to remember what Christ has done for us. The elements of bread and wine merely serve as visual aids to help us in this act of remembrance. They remind us of His body given for us and His blood shed for us. Nothing happens to them, in them, or through them. They remain bread and wine.

Everyone would agree that the bread and wine do help us to remember, but is that really all they do? At the other extreme were Reformers who took a position very similar to the Roman Catholics. This was the position of Luther and his followers. For them, the bread and the wine actually do become the body and blood of Christ so that when we eat the bread and drink the wine at Communion, we are, quite literally, eating Christ’s body and drinking Christ’s blood.

Many wanted to say that more is happening than mere remembrance. But are we really physically eating Christ’s flesh and drinking Him blood? A third alternative was taken by those who were not happy in seeing the bread and the wine as physically body and blood, but who could not accept that nothing is happening except an act of remembrance. They argued that that while the bread and wine remains physically bread and wine, they nevertheless became the means by which spiritually we eat Christ’s body and drink his blood. The bread and wine so represent Christ’s body and blood that they enable us by faith to feed on Christ spiritually. This was the position of Calvin. Calvin also argued that Holy Communion should take place each week and should be at the heart of the Church.

Strangely, those who followed Calvin more generally in his teaching in the Reformed Churches, largely did not follow him in his understanding and the practice of Holy Communion. Ironically, it was Anglicanism that did not follow Calvin more generally on other matters that took up his position on Holy Communion. It is Calvin’s understanding that is reflected, broadly speaking, in the Anglican liturgy we use Sunday by Sunday. Although with Anglicanism being Anglicanism, you will find Anglicans at each of the extremes and at all points in between!

What do you think? What do you think is happening in our service of Eucharist this morning? What are you doing when you eat the bread and drink the wine? And, perhaps more importantly, does it matter? To attempt an answer to these questions, let us think for a moment about why we do this in the first place.

On the night before he died, Jesus had a Last Meal with His disciples, a meal that the Gospel writers tell us that He went to some trouble to arrange. It mattered to Him that it took place. The Meal had the character of a Passover Meal. This was a meal celebrated annually by the Jewish people, then as now. Jesus reinterpreted this sacred Jewish meal, which remembered the deliverance from Egypt, to refer to Himself and His soon to be death. He famously told them to do this in remembrance of Him.

So seriously did His disciples take this that their re-creation of the Last Supper took place weekly, and not annually, as was the case with the original Passover Meal. Incredibly, within 20 years of Jesus’ death, we know that this Meal was the centre of Christian worship in churches of Gentiles in Greece.

In our reading from 1 Corinthians 11, Paul tells us that he had passed on to the Corinthians what had been passed on to him, namely the details of the Last Supper. This meal was something they too shared in week by week in their gatherings. It was not an optional extra or something at the periphery of the Christian faith, but something central to it.

What is more, it is clear from what Paul writes to the Corinthians that it was understood as far more than act of remembrance. Paul elsewhere in 1 Corinthians describes it as ‘participation’ in Christ’s body and blood. So seriously does Paul take it that he believes that the reason why some of the Corinthians have become sick or have died is because of their failure to celebrate the Lord’s Supper properly.

Jesus went to great trouble to institute this meal, a practice established by how seriously His first followers took it. But why? Why did Jesus want His disciples to do this in remembrance of Him?

I think that John gives us the answer in the Gospel reading for this morning. John does not describe the actual institution of the Eucharist. Instead, he gives us an account of Jesus’ teaching in the synagogue in Capernaum. Jesus tells those listening that He is the Living Bread. But then He says, ‘Very truly’ – in other words He wants His hearers to take what follows very seriously indeed – ‘Very truly, I tell you, unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you.’

Even more startling He says, ‘Whoever eats me will live because of me’

This very graphic way of speaking was just too much for his audience in the synagogue, who could not understand how they could eat His flesh or drink his blood. What is more, it was too much for many of His disciples who, we are told, stopped following Him because of what He had said.

Jesus is not saying that they should indulge in cannibalism as if chewing on His arm would do them any good, but that they must feed on Him in the sense that they must become as dependent on Him for life as they are dependent on food and drink. He is to be the source of their life, the basis on which they live, the One they worship and follow. This is to be a dependency and reliance on him that goes beyond faith and obedience. It is a complete identification with Him so that life without Him becomes not only undesirable, but impossible and unthinkable.

Those who so feed and depend on Christ in this way are promised that they will have eternal life. This is not just life after death, although it includes that, but life here and now.

His disciples who left him realized what this means and what it entails. It means abandoning trust and reliance on anything or anyone else ourselves included. It means relying solely and absolutely on Jesus for life, strength, and fulfilment: not money, not family, not our own achievements, not our own resources, nor anything else, but only on Christ. It is not just a spiritual reliance whereby we depend on Christ in, for example, our prayer life. It is a complete spiritual, emotional, psychological, and intellectual dependence on Him in which our physical welfare becomes of no consequence compared to doing His will.

One of the accusations frequently made against Christians is that we are weak people, who cannot make it on our own. We need an emotional and psychological crutch. The truth, however, is that we are not weak enough. We think we can rely on Christ and ….. and money, and career, and our gifts and abilities. But, as Paul put it, it is only when we realize our own weakness, only when we abandon all hope and trust in ourselves, only when we are so utterly crushed and broken that it is only on Christ that we depend, then, and only then, will we know the power of God. For the power of God is made perfect in weakness.

What is the source of my life here in the present? What is my hope for life in the future? What is my strength? Not my intellect. Not my gifts. Not my status or position. Not my wealth or influence. Nothing, but Christ.

‘Nothing in my hand I bring,Simply to the cross I cling;Naked, come to Thee for dress;Helpless look to Thee for grace;Foul, I to the fountain fly;Wash me, Savior, or I die.’

Paul writes: ‘Yet whatever gains I had, these I have come to regard as loss because of Christ. More than that, I regard everything as loss because of the surpassing value of knowing Christ Jesus my Lord. For his sake I have suffered the loss of all things, and I regard them as rubbish, in order that I may gain Christ …’ (Philippians 3:7-8) And this is what Jesus means when He says:

‘Very truly, I tell you unless you eat the flesh of the Son of Man and drink his blood, you have no life in you.’

For Jesus’ words this morning are not just a promise, but a statement of a stark reality: it is only by feeding on Christ that we can have life. This feeding on Christ begins when we first trust in Christ and commit ourselves to Him, but it is a feeding that must be continual. It is in Holy Communion supremely that we do this. Here the benefits of Christ’s death are made available to us. Here we are united with Him in his death. And here the benefits of his death are made available to us for without the death of Christ nothing would be possible.

Paul writes: ‘For as often as you eat this bread and drink the cup, you proclaim the Lord’s death until he comes’. As we meet each week for Holy Communion, we proclaim that it is only in the death of Christ that life may be found, and we call others to join us in this life. We also pronounce the judgement of God on this world and its values. We tell the world so confident in its power, strength, and wealth that it is only in the humiliation, weakness, and poverty of the Cross that the true God is to be found. Here Sunday by Sunday the world is judged and its idols laid bare.

We gather here today to feed on Christ and to receive from him all we need for life both now and forever.

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Following Up

You will have gathered from my previous post that I was very upset not only because of the nature of the offensive comments that the BBC broadcast on the radio programme the Newsquiz on May 25, but also by the arrogance of their response - or lack of it. They point blank refused to discuss it, let alone apologize.

I did ask if there was any other way I could complain. They just ignored the question. I now discover that complaints can also be made to Ofcom, an official body. I have sent them a complaint.

I have never complained before and only wanted to make the point that there have to be self-imposed limits to comedy in a decent society. The comedians concerned would despise anyone making jokes about race. If it is right to respect race, which it is, then we should respect religion as well. The people at organisations such as the BBC in the UK need to realize this and they will only realize it if those of us who feel this way complain in a reasonable way.

I will let you know how this goes. Given the way my complaint has been handled so far, I am not overly optimistic.

Monday, June 11, 2007

Dear All

At the end of May, I listened to a recording of the BBC Radio 4 Programme, the Newsquiz, online. I have been listening to this programme for as long as I can remember. It is very funny and often quite intelligent. Whatever, I enjoy it.

As part of it, you have to accept that they will make fun of everyone and everything. That's the deal. I accept that, and have laughed with them about all sorts of topics, religious ones included. I have to accept that if we religious people make a mess of it, we deserve to be made fun of.

However, in this broadcast I felt they went too far. Way too far. The joke was about a virgin shark. They joked about Jesus coming again in a fish. I thought this exceeded the bounds of good taste by any standards. Still, I thought just a mild complaint would be enough. I don't like a lot of fuss.

Have you ever complained to the BBC? They make it as difficult as possible. To cut a long story short. I complained via their website. They refused to deal with my complaint. I complained again. Same response. I complained again. They gave me a telephone number. All the while saying they could not give me a specific address to write to and insisting I had to begin from the beginning. The idea is that you lose energy.

I phoned. The person who answered said she hadn't a clue what I was talking about and couldn't waste her time talking to me. I tried to give her the reference, but she refused to take it. I am sure the BBC have the tape of the conversation. I kept saying that all I wanted was for the BBC to take my complaint seriously. After nine minutes, I was told to get off the phone.

We are fair game as are others in the public eye. I think we take it in good spirits most of the time. However, I do not think it is on to make jokes like this about anyone's religion. IT"S NOT FUNNY.

The reason why Muslims are offended by western culture is that it can be offensive. It is often offensive to me as a Christian and, hopefully, to members of other religions too. These sort of comments offend decency.

The broadcasters really are locked in a world of their own.

Friday, June 08, 2007

Some Thoughts on Paul

Well, I have had better weeks! I have felt that I have been running around a lot this week, but not really achieveing anything. One thing I did do this week was give a talk at the monthly meeting for Anglican clergy in Hong Kong. At every meeting someone is asked to lead people's thoughts on the readings for the forthcoming Sunday. This Sunday, the epistle is from the first chapter of Galatians. I took the opportunity to give some random thoughts on Paul in the light of his comments in Galatians that anyone who disagreed with him should be damned!

Ironically, we are not having this reading at Christ Church on Sunday as we are following the Roman Catholic practice of celebrating Corpus Christi on the Sunday after the day it falls on. In the Anglican calendar it is also more delicately referred to as Day of Thanksgiving for the Instituion of Holy Communion, doubtless to avoid offending any protestant sensibilities. Corpus Christi (Latin for Body of Christ) is, of course, its traditional name and I see no point in not using it.

Protestant attitudes to Communion can be confusing. While Zwingli amongst the Reformers did not see anything special happening at Communion, Luther and Calvin did. True, they criticised what they saw as abuses in the Roman Mass, but they did not throw the baby out with the bath water in the way many of their followers subsequently have. Anyway, my next post in the series, Where I am Now will be on the Eucharist!

Until then, here is the talk I gave for the clergy on Thursday. I wonder what you think?

Some Thoughts on Paul

In his first letter to the Corinthians in chapters 8 to 10, Paul writes about ‘food offered to idols’. As many will know, in pagan cities such as Corinth, animals were sacrificed in the temples. The meat from these sacrifices was then either sold in the meat market or consumed in banquets held in the temple itself. The temples were the social clubs of the city. They were places to meet, to socialize, and to do business. And where you get men and money, you also get sex. Prostitution was commonly associated with the life of the temple

The Corinthians came from this background where going to the temple to eat – and have sex – was a normal part of city life, and where buying meat from the temple at the market was a normal practice. But what about now they were Christians?

Some of the Corinthians argued that nothing needed to change. Paul quotes them as saying, ‘ we know no idol in the world really exists’, and, ‘ there is no God, but one’. They knew that the idol the animal was sacrificed to did not exist. Furthermore, they were not bound by law, ‘all things were lawful’ to them. In other words, they could do what they felt right. What then did it matter if they went to the temple to eat? The idol didn’t exist. What did it matter if they ate meat bought at the market? This was the logical outworking of what was, after all, Paul’s own Gospel.

Paul agrees with the premise, but not the conclusion. It is true that an idol does not exist. However, not all Christians in Corinth believed this. For them going to the temple was as if they were worshipping the idol. Besides, there is, argues Paul, a spiritual reality behind the idol. Concern for our brother and sister ought to come first before our own rights and knowledge in the matter. In any case, prostituion is always wrong.

As for meat sold in the market, Paul himself is convinced that there is no reason why Christians should not buy and eat it. If, however, my eating meat offends another Christian, then it is wrong to eat it. What matters is love and unity between Christians. They should avoid giving offence to one another and be prepared to limit their freedom out of consideration for one another.

He concludes his argument:

So, whether you eat or drink, or whatever you do, do everything for the glory of God. Give no offence to Jews or to Greeks or to the church of God, just as I try to please everyone in everything I do, not seeking my own advantage, but that of many, so that they may be saved. Be imitators of me, as I am of Christ. (1 Corinthians 10:31-11:1)

This sort of approach, avoiding giving offence and concentrating on the unity of the Church, was Paul’s approach generally and not just in Corinth. In his letter to the Romans, he again has to deal with arguments over food. Here it is not food offered to idols, but the issue of what is clean and unclean. This was a big issue for Jewish-Christians. Some in the Church would eat anything; some would not eat any meat in case it was unclean. Some saw some days as holy, presumably Jewish-Christians, while others saw all days as being the same.

Paul’s own position is, again, clear. He sides with the strong, that is, with those who eat anything and who see all days as the same. But again, Paul argues what matters is not what a person thinks right, but the effect it has on a brother or sister. Christians are not to pass judgement on other Christians and what they do. Each is to be persuaded in their own mind. Both positions should co-exist. Each is doing what they do to honour the Lord and that’s what counts. We must not cause our brother or sister to stumble. It is better not to eat than to offend a brother or sister for whom Christ died.

He tells them:

‘The faith that you have, have as your own conviction before God.’ (Romans 14:22)

This is the liberal Paul: tolerant, inclusive, open and accepting; rejecting fundamentalism and asserting the right of the individual to make up their own mind before God alongside the need to respect conscience and avoid giving offence. It is a Paul who would be very much at home in western, liberal Christianity.

Then we come to Galatians.

We must remember, in reading Galatians, this liberal Paul because in Galatians it is a very different Paul who emerges. Interesting another argument over food is at the heart of the epistle. I will quote from what Paul says:

‘But when Cephas came to Antioch, I opposed him to his face, because he stood self-condemned; for until certain people came from James, he used to eat with the Gentiles. But after they came, he drew back and kept himself separate for fear of the circumcision faction. And the other Jews joined him in this hypocrisy, so that even Barnabas was led astray by their hypocrisy. But when I saw that they were not acting consistently with the truth of the gospel, I said to Cephas before them all, "If you, though a Jew, live like a Gentile and not like a Jew, how can you compel the Gentiles to live like Jews?"” (Galatians 2:11-14)

In Antioch, Jewish and Gentile Christians ate together. For strict Jewish-Christians this practice was unacceptable as it compromised ritual purity. So when ‘men from James’ come to Antioch from Jerusalem, the Jewish-Christians, including Peter and Barnabas, out of respect, stopped eating with the Gentile Christians. Paul, rather than sympathizing with their desire not to give offence, condemned them for their hypocrisy.

It is against the background of this argument that Galatians is written. The Jewish-Christians from James were also, it seems, insisting that Paul’s converts in Galatia should be circumcised and keep the Law. That is, in order to have unity in the Church and full table-fellowship, they argued that Gentiles should adopt the same lifestyle as the Jewish-Christians. It is important to stress that these Jewish-Christians were not anti-Gentile. Paul himself describes them as zealous for the Galatians. They too wanted to avoid offence, preserve Church unity, and have a common basis for fellowship. What is more, the Galatians themselves were not upset at this argument and seem to have been willing to comply with the Jewish-Christians' request. It was, it seems, only Paul who had the problem!

Not only that, Paul himself seems to have been the problem for many of them. They attacked Paul as preaching a Gospel of his own in not requiring the Galatian Christians to be circumcised. They argued that the Christians in Galatia should follow the example of the mother church in Jerusalem and the apostles who knew the Lord, not this maverick Paul.

Attacks on the authority of Paul were common then as now. But before we use the attacks then as the basis for the attacks now, it is worth reminding ourselves that Paul and his opponents had much in common. They believed the same scriptures, had the same Christology, and accepted the same basic structure of the Christian faith. Paul passed on what had been passed on to him, especially, but not only, that 'Christ died for our sins and on the third day rose again'.

The common argument that Paul invented something new, something different from what Jesus preached and was first believed, is not supported by the evidence. What Paul and the Jewish-Christians were arguing over were the Gentiles. Everything else they agreed on. What Paul is supposed to have invented already existed before he came on the scene. This is, indeed, part of the Jewish-Christians’ argument. They got there first and so should be believed before Paul.

What Paul was saying that was new was that Jews and Gentiles were both Christians and members of the Church on the same basis as each other, namely, that of faith. There was no need for the Gentiles in addition to be circumcised and keep the Law. However, Paul goes further than arguing that it is unnecessary. He sees the requirement that they should be circumcised as a perversion of the Gospel. What is more, if they are circumcised Christ will be of no use to them. The Jewish-Christians concerned are enemies of the Cross of Christ. The Galatians must listen to Paul and hold fast to the freedom that God has given them.

Precisely why Paul was so opposed to the Gentiles being circumcised, especially when the Gentiles themselves were quite happy to be, is a question which is too quickly passed over in my opinion, but that must wait for another day. What is important here is the question of where Paul got the authority for his position. Quite simply, he claims, he received it directly from God himself:

“For I want you to know, brothers and sisters, that the gospel that was proclaimed by me is not of human origin; for I did not receive it from a human source, nor was I taught it, but I received it through a revelation of Jesus Christ.” (Galatians 1:11-12)

If anyone preaches anything different to Paul, then they are wrong. He states boldly:

‘Am I now seeking human approval, or God’s approval? Or am I trying to please people? If I were still pleasing people, I would not be a servant of Christ.’ (Galatians 1:10)

This is the absolute Paul, the Calvinist Paul, intolerant of any view that he sees as compromising the Gospel, confident in his faith, willing to divide the Church for what he believes to be true and unwilling to let anyone get in his way. This is a Paul who would be at home in the Church in Nigeria or Sydney.

Two different Paul’s, listen to them again:

1 Corinthians 10:32-33: ‘Give no offence to Jews or to Greeks or to the church of God, just as I try to please everyone in everything I do, not seeking my own advantage, but that of many, so that they may be saved.’

Galatians 1:10: ‘‘Am I now seeking human approval, or God’s approval? Or am I trying to please people? If I were still pleasing people, I would not be a servant of Christ.’

How do we reconcile the two? How do we do justice to these two Paul’s, or two sides to Paul’s teaching.

Paul went out of his way to preserve the unity of the Church. He was prepared to compromise to a breath-taking degree to avoid division, even to the extent of having his co-worker Timothy circumcised, notwithstanding what he says about circumcision in Galatians. It is true he could justify it because Timothy’s mother was Jewish, but it shows how flexible Paul was prepared to be.

However, when it came to something that he saw as lying at the heart of the Christian faith, he was immoveable. For Paul the requirement for the Gentiles to be circumcised compromised the truth of the gospel. (As I said, quite why is another issue!) Again, in these days when it is common to condemn Paul for extremism and arrogance, it is worth reminding ourselves that most of us think he was right. At least no-one has suggested to me recently that I need to be circumcised. We cannot cite the argument in Galatia as an example of why we think Paul was wrong while agreeing with what he says.

The bottom line was the Gospel. And Paul believed the truth of the Gospel was at stake in the issue of circumcision in a way it was not in the issue of food offered to idols and that of clean and unclean food.

In the Church today there is a conflict between those who want to follow the relative line that Paul promotes in Corinth and Rome, and those who want to follow the absolute line that he takes in Galatia.

In Anglicanism, for example, some see the issue of homosexuality, like circumcision, in absolute terms. On the one side, there are those who argue we must permit it if we believe the Gospel. On the other, there those who argue that we should forbid it for precisely the same reason. For both it is a defining issue, one that cannot be compromised on.

Others, such as those who follow the Windsor report, see the issue, like food offered to idols, in relative terms. There are differences of opinion that must be listened to and respected, but what matters most is love of each other and the unity of the Church. Compromise is essential.

I do not wish to discuss the gay issue here. I do want to say though that the reason why Paul could be both relative and absolute at times and still live with himself was because he was clear in his own mind what the Gospel was. He knew what was the basis of his faith. He defined this a lot more minimally and generously than many give him credit for, but he did define it and was prepared to defend it.

Part of our problem today, I would suggest, is that we are unable to say exactly what the Gospel essentially is. What it is that must be believed by everyone, everywhere. Paul believed that the Gospel was not something negotiable, something to be discovered and defined by humans. He believed it was a gift from God carrying divine authority. This was why it was good news that had the power to save.

Until we too know what the Gospel is, we are not going to be in a position to save anyone.

Wednesday, June 06, 2007

Where I am Now: 2. Theologically Orthodox

I have written earlier about how I came to prefer the description orthodox Christian as a way of describing my theological beliefs. (See Personal Journey 14) I am more and more convinced that we need to rethink the old labels we give ourselves and others: evangelical, charismatic, liberal, catholic, and so on. This is not to say, as some Christians argue, that labels are without use. After all, as someone once said to me, ‘without a label you don’t know what is in the package’! Labels can be useful as a shorthand for describing what we believe and where it is we are coming from. Equally, labels can be restrictive, narrowing who we are and whom we are willing to speak to.

Perhaps more seriously, the labels can over time become out of date so that a label that once said something meaningful is now irrelevant because the debate has moved on. At the risk of being provocative, I think this is true of some of the labels that came out of the reformation, but which are still used by Christians today. Even labels such as evangelical and charismatic are, I suggest problematic, originating as they do in specific historical circumstances, one in eighteen century England, the other in renewal movement of the 1960s and 1970s. What matters, surely, is not the continuing use of labels that describe products now pass their sell by date, but what these products originally represented and how what is still good in them can be preserved in a way that is relevant to the changed circumstances of our day.

Was it necessary for Protestants to protest against abuses in the then Roman Catholic Church? On the whole, yes. Was it right for evangelicals to stress the authority of Scripture against the exaltation of human reason in the enlightenment? Undoubtedly. Were charismatics right to call for a renewal of the church and a rediscovery of the Holy Spirit? Absolutely. But we cannot be fighting the battles of the past over and over again when there are serious issues to be faced in the present.

Roman Catholics may have different beliefs to those who are not, but surely most of us think the Pope is a Christian and not the anti-Christ? Is it evangelicals only who are saved? Do only charismatics experience the Holy Spirit?

What we need is a coming together of Christians who can share the fundamental beliefs of the Christian faith. What are these? Here generosity is called for. Some Christians would define these so tightly that they exclude everyone, but their own kind. Others would define them so loosely that they have no meaning. Others are opposed to any attempt to define the Christian faith believing in an open faith that is always changing.

I believe that the real issue in present day Christianity has to do with whether the Bible is trustworthy and whether the Creeds are an accurate and reliable statement of the Christian faith. There is a myth of Christian origins doing the rounds that the Da Vinci Code tapped into and which is believed by many Christians. I regard this as the most dangerous heresy facing the Church today. It is a myth that questions the reliability of the four canonical Gospels, criticizes the role of Paul, gives credibility to Gnosticism, and challenges the authority of the Creeds and the nature of the canon.

It is perhaps not surprising that they attack the foundation because once the foundation falls all those of whose faith is built on it fall with it. We need to accept that there have been errors in the past and that our labels reflect this, but what we need now is for all who accept the Bible and the Creeds to put aside their differences and strive together for the faith once and for all delivered to the saints.

What is more, if orthodox Christians can get together there will be an added benefit. As we come out of our ghettos, we can listen to one another and learn from one another as we hear what God has been doing with each of us while we have been apart.

I am not advocating a lowest common denominator approach, nor am I saying that the various groups should sacrifice what is dear to them, just that we should be prepared to work together with those who share an orthodox faith. A coalition of the orthodox is what I am advocating.

Anyway that’s where I am. I value all I have learnt in the past as an evangelical and charismatic, and I don’t reject it. I just want more. I want to be able to explore the Christian faith and its meaning for today learning from the past, but not being limited by it or to it. I want to listen and talk to those not from my tradition and hear what they have to say. I want to present the Gospel to people in a way they can understand and hopefully respond to. And I want to resist the attempt to abandon the authority of the Bible and rewrite the Creeds.

Coming from an Anglican background, I am gratified that that was originally what Anglicans stood for!

Monday, June 04, 2007

Where I am Now: 1. Mission

For a while now I have been writing an account of my own personal journey. These blogs haven’t been planned except in a general way, and I have been following my thoughts as I have gone along. Thank you to all who have stayed with it. I have paused somewhat in recent blogs to examine some of the challenges I see in ministering here at Christ Church. While I have written from a personal point of view, they are, nevertheless, challenges I think anyone would face ministering here.

Perhaps now I ought to resume the account of my journey by asking where I am personally. So, in the next few blogs in this series, I am going to ask myself where I am now in my journey. Today I want to think a little about mission.

Where I am Now: 1. Mission

I came to Hong Kong via Jerusalem believing going to Hong Kong a particularly significant move. That turned out to be an understatement. (I have written in a previous blog about the changes in my personal circumstances early on in my time here.) I came via Jerusalem as I saw this as a symbolic way of making a commitment to mission in the next stage of my ministry. This was were it all began.

One thing that has not changed during my time here, though, is the commitment I feel to mission. At Banchory, I was sure that it had to be at the heart of our life as Church. It was also why I had got as involved as I had in Mission 21, a Scottish Episcopal initiative in mission. When I arrived in Hong Kong, I was also sure that it should be at the heart of my ministry here. I think that when I came, I believed the biggest challenge would be engaging in mission in a different culture. And yes, there are cultural differences. And yes all that has been written about being sensitive to people in a different culture are true. However globalisation has ensured that many of the issues facing the Church are the same the world over, certainly in the developed world.

The issue for me personally increasingly has become what it is we mean by ‘mission’. One of the reasons I am interested in the emerging church movement, while having reservations about aspects of it, is that I believe those in the movement are asking the right questions, and are putting mission at the centre of the debate about what it means to be the Church in a post-modern world.

Mission, however, must be about more than getting seats filled. This seems to be so obvious as not to need stating, and yet I wonder how many of us clergy especially are unconsciously working with a numbers based model of church growth. Whenever I talk to people who think their Church is growing, the first thing they tell me is that there are more people attending services. And I want people to attend services as much as anyone. But is this really the most important sign of church growth?

I would go further. Mission and church growth need to be about more than people becoming Christians. At every baptism service, I read the passage from Matthew 28, Jesus’ words to the eleven disciples before he left them. They are well-known, but I think we sometimes miss their message:

‘All authority in heaven and on earth has been given to me. Go therefore and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything that I have commanded you. And remember, I am with you always, to the end of the age.’

The making of disciples involves baptizing people of all nations, which I take to mean convincing them that Jesus is Lord and that they should make a personal commitment to him. It also involves teaching them to obey everything that Jesus commanded his disciples. In other words, being a disciple, today as then, means more than just believing in Jesus, it means a day by day, moment by moment, life of obedience.

‘Trust and obey
for there’s no other way,
to be happy in Jesus,
but to trust and obey.’

This, however, requires us to develop a Christian lifestyle and worldview: something that will often mean going against the prevailing worldview and its values and beliefs. It may even make us unpopular.

This is where I feel more and more concerned in my own ministry. In the Church, we are simply failing to resist the values of the world in which we live. It is not that our members aren’t sincere or don’t believe. They do. It’s just that all too often it doesn’t make any practical difference. Our values and lifestyles are not significantly different to those of the culture around us. We educate our kids at the same schools, with the same goals and ideals as the kids of parents with no Christian faith. We pursue careers, buy houses, have families, watch TV programmes, read books and magazines, surf the internet, consume material goods, relax and play all in essentially the same way and with the same attitudes as the rest of society.

When I ask myself what difference being a Christian makes, I am disturbed by the answer the evidence suggests I should give. When recently I said to leading member of my own church that the Christian faith called into question making money as the key factor in making decisions in life, they told me not to be silly and that was something that only Vicars believed. Of course, we had to say that in church, but it was only an ideal that no-one took seriously outside.

I do not want a return to where I have come from; where things were rejected as worldly simply because people in the world enjoyed them. Nor do I want a withdrawal from the world and for Christians to be different for the sake of it. But if we are to teach people to obey everything that Jesus taught, surely that will mean, as Jesus himself suggested, a certain sort of difference?

Another aspect of this is the way the entertainment culture has penetrated the Church. We expect to be entertained when we come to Church, not challenged. We want to be given things to enjoy, not called upon to sacrifice them in obedience to Christ. In our desire to get numbers, to have people listen to us, and to take us seriously, we have rewritten the Gospel to leave out the parts that we think people will find unattractive.

The Church community needs to engage faithfully in mission, but that means speaking the truth as it is. If that attracts some, while driving others away, then that is something, albeit with sadness, we may have to accept. Jesus certainly had to. Clearly, it is not what we want, and we should strive to avoid putting any obstacle in people’s way. But we need to ask whether rather than engaging in mission, what we are unwittingly doing is developing the Church as place of spiritual entertainment where success is measured by the criteria of the box office.

Perhaps we have to accept smaller numbers and less worldly success in favour of communities which take the challenge to obey Jesus’ teaching seriously and which are prepared to make the sacrifices necessary to do that. Mission remains a priority for me, but more and more I find myself forced to define what it is I mean by it.

Thursday, May 31, 2007

Present Challenges: Conclusion

I have been Vicar of Christ Church, Kowloon Tong for 7 years. In this series of posts, I have been trying to examine some of the Challenges that I see facing myself and the Church.

On the positive side, Christ Church is a Church with a tradition and strong roots in the local community. Given that we are an English-speaking Church this is very important. We have a wide circle of adherents, that is, people who feel attached to the Church even if they are not regulars at the services. We also have a committed core who support the regualr life of the Church. Services are well-attended. We are in a good position financially with our buildings in a sound condition. We attract many young families because of the Schools, one of the benefits of which is a thriving Sunday School. People who come to Christ Church frequently comment on the friendliness and the warmth of welcome they experience here. Meetings are free from acrimony and there is little argument or divisiveness. This, and much more besides, is a cause for thankfulness.

However, as I have said, I do still think there are serious challenges that need to be faced. Essentially, they all come down to the question of how we can grow spiritually and avoid the danger, as I wrote last time, of being simply a successful, spiritual club. Growing spiritually, as I see it, means 'growing in knowledge and love of the Lord' and engaging in mission. We have amazing opportunities for mission because of the numbers of people seeking baptism and places at the Schools. The problem here occurs because those in this position seem to be uninterested in anything other than advancing their children’s educational careers.

It would help if I had some help. It would make a huge difference to have some clergy support. This need not be full-time stipendiary support. What we call a NSM (a non-stipendiary minister) would make a great deal of difference. There are such people around in Hong Kong; unfortunately, they are attracted to ministry at the Cathedral, which makes for a real imbalance in clergy provision amongst the English-speaking Anglican Churches here. I don’t wish to complain, but being the only clergyman in a Church of this size is very demanding, and means that most of my time and energy is spent on maintenance rather than mission. So while we have the financial and material resources we need as a Church, we do not have the ministerial resources we need to meet the challenges that face us.

Perhaps I am being unduly pessimistic. If I am, then it is only because I find it tragic that we are not fulfilling our spiritual potential and as the spiritual leader of the Church, I must bare the responsibility for our failure to do so. I am convinced that renewing the Church spiritually must now and in the next few years be our priority just as renewing the buildings has been in the past few years. Quite how to achieve this is another question altogether! I’ll keep you informed as to how we get on.

Friday, May 25, 2007

Present Challenges: 5. The Problem of Inclusivity

When I began blogging, Blogger did not allow you to label posts. This changed some time ago, and I have been going back giving labels to previous posts. This means it is possible to find posts on similar subjects or in a series. So clicking Personal Journey will display all the blogs in this ongoing series together. It also means I can refer to previous posts more easily. Seasoned bloggers will know all this already, of course. Others are far more sophisticated in their blogging than me. I hope the relative simplicity of this blog does not spoil it for anyone. I really do appreciate the time people spend reading what I have to say even though my posts are not always as regular as I would like them to be. I am working on this - I promise!

In recent posts labelled Present Challenges, I have been trying to face honestly some of the specific challenges here in Hong Kong that I find myself facing in this stage of my personal journey. I have identified four so far:

1. Baptism
2. The Schools
3. The Congregation
4. The Buildings

I will make the last post about present challenges today before I get completely depressed! I am calling it the Challenge of Inclusivity. Appropriately it will bring me back, after a short detour, to my Personal Journey.

In my next blog, I will offer a conclusion to this short series. After that, I will attempt to explain where I personally am now and where I see myself going. This is going to be interesting because while I think I know where I am, I am not so sure I know where I am going! I know where I would like to go, but that is another matter!

Present Challenges: 5. The Challenge of Inclusivity

Depending on how many of my previous blogs you have read, you will know that my Christian origins lay in a very evangelical and charismatic context. Over the years, I have found myself ministering outside of this context while remaining sympathetic to many of its emphases. The advantage of ministering in a definite theological context is that you know where you are and where your congregation is. You can reasonably confidently make assumptions about what people believe, think, and experience.

In Moreton, for example, as a curate, I could assume that people believed the Bible to be reliable and authoritative and that the Holy Spirit could be experienced in a certain way in the present. In Banchory, the congregation was far more diverse. Some did indeed believe that the Bible was reliable and authoritative, but others saw it merely as one source of authority and one that needed to be interpreted and applied with caution.

At Banchory I decided to make a virtue out of necessity, namely, out of the diversity. While at Bedford, working in a secular context, I had seen first-hand how irrelevant the Church was to most people’s lives. It wasn’t that people weren’t interested in spiritual things; it was just that they did not go to the Church to find out about them. I had come to feel that the Church needed to be far more outward looking and less focused on internal disputes.

I also came to believe that the emphasis on 'theme' churches was bad. By 'theme' churches I mean congregations that follow one theological tradition whether it be liberal, Catholic, evangelical, or whatever. In my preaching and teaching. I stressed tolerance, inclusivity, and open-mindedness. This did not mean that we couldn’t have strongly held views of our own, but that we should also be accepting of other people’s strongly held views.

In my own ministry, I began from the assumption that the Creeds were true and that I did not have to cross my fingers when saying them and that the Bible was reliable and, therefore, should be the basis for my preaching and teaching. Liturgically, I worked with a Catholic approach centred on the Eucharist. I encouraged people to think and to discuss without dividing and separating. How successful or otherwise this approach was is for others to judge, but I felt it was right and provided the foundation for mission and Church growth. My overwhelming concern was to ‘invite, welcome, and include’ those outside the Church.

When I came to Hong Kong, I brought these principles and attitudes with me. The worship at Christ Church was very similar in focus to how it had been at Banchory. That is, a fairly conservative liturgy, Catholic in nature, centred on the Eucharist. Christ Church itself was, by tradition and choice, open and liberal in attitude so in many ways it should have been business as normal in my own ministry. Increasingly, however I have become concerned about the way an emphasis on inclusivity can be used as a cover for blandness and indifference.

I still believe passionately in being inclusive in our welcome of people. I also believe in tolerance and openness to one another. The problem I see with this approach, however, is the way it leads to an abandoning of aspects of the Christian message that sound exclusive or may be thought to put people off and also in the way it can result in a modification of our view of God. (See my series on Changing our View of God). In my own spiritual life, I think I avoided this, at least to an extent, by continuing to believe in the Bible and the Creeds, but I am not sure I was very successful in helping others to avoid it.

Furthermore, in a congregation that is not particularly focused on teaching and faith, and which is not especially motivated to meet together for Bible study (see my recent post on Buildings), tolerance and acceptance can be no more than indifference and apathy. That is, we get on with one another not because we respect each others views and opinions, but because we can’t be bothered having any views or opinions of our own, and still less bothered in finding out about other people’s.

It is easier in a theme church because everyone is left in no doubt about the terms on which they are there. If you are part of such a Church there are certain things you must believe and do – or not do – to be accepted as part of the community. The challenge for me is to know how to accept diversity and, at the same time, to encourage spiritual growth.

A feature of Hong Kong life is that many people are members of social clubs. This is because of the size and nature of the places where people live. Clubs make it possible for people to socialize and have access to facilities that there just isn’t the space for in high rise apartments in a crowded city. Each club has their own identity, but you don’t have to sign up to any statement of belief to belong to one. You just pay your monthly membership fee. I am very worried that both here, and elsewhere in the Christian world, Churches are just becoming clubs. There is a vague spirituality about them, but as along as you pay your fees no-one is going to question or challenge you.

This fits well with the social climate and mood of the day where judgement is out and acceptance is in and where all values and beliefs are relative. Christians are being seduced by it, which is why we prefer a Benevolent God who always loves us and forgives us to One who may occasionally disapprove of us and what we do. I think we have to face up to the extreme selectivity we are engaging in when we follow this line of thought. We stress Jesus’ eating and drinking with sinners and constantly tell and re-tell the parable of the sower, but keep quiet about Jesus saying he came to bring a sword and to divide families. And parables about eternal punishment rarely get an airing.

Please don’t misunderstand me. I don’t want to return to the days when Christianity was more about fear than forgiveness. I am increasingly challenged, however, to find a way in which both themes can be kept together. I am especially challenged when I see individual Christians and, indeed, whole congregations not really thinking it matters what you believe or do as long as you get on with one another.

Monday, May 21, 2007

Rained Off?

At Christ Church, we have two morning services, the first at 8.00am and the second at 10.00am. Yesterday it was raining very heavily, so heavily that I got soaked just walking the short distance from the Vicarage to Church. Despite the terrible weather, the congregation at 8.00am was completely normal in size. At 10.00am, however, it was at least one third down. I don’t quite know what this shows, but it is interesting, nevertheless.

My sermon at 10.00am was on the conversion of the Philippian gaoler and his question, What must I do to be saved? (The sermon is available in audio form on the Christ Church website so I won’t repeat it here). The question itself, somehow, sounds very old-fashioned. It shows how our way of understanding the Gospel is somewhat different to how it was understood in the past. I am not sure even us Christians think we need saving. Perhaps if we did, people wouldn’t stay away from Church because it is raining!

Anyway, the rainy season is well and truly upon us, and it looks like being wet for the rest of the week. Maybe it will encourage me, too, to stay in and write my blog!

Have a good week!

Thursday, May 17, 2007

The Brothers of our Lord

Readers of this blog may remember that I recently wrote about a book by Richard Bauckham, Jesus and the Eyewitnesses. I enjoyed it so much that I bought his earlier book, Jude and the Relatives of Jesus, which I am half way through. It, too, is a fascinating and enjoyable book.

Amongst other things, I must confess that 1 Corinthians 9:5 had not made the impact on me that perhaps it should have. Paul writes: ‘Do we not have the right to be accompanied by a believing wife, as do the other apostles and the brothers of the Lord and Cephas?’ The point is that he mentions the ‘brothers of the Lord’ as a distinct group who travelled around with their wives preaching and teaching for Jesus.

It reminds me of how much we don’t know about what was going on in the first years of the Church and how easy it is to impose a later perspective on it. It is so important to read the Bible in its historical context. This calls for some imagination as we try to picture what life really was like.

I remember the first time I went to Galilee. I was shocked by how small the Sea of Galilee was. I imagine that if we could travel back in time to the time of Jesus and the early days of the Church, there would be many such shocks and surprises! Time travel, sadly, is not an option, instead we must rely on the glimpses that work such as Bauckham’s gives us.
Christ Church: The Building - A Picture

I thought I would have a go at posting a picture following on from yesterday's blog.

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Present Challenges: 4. Church Buildings

I had to work away from Hong Kong for a few days which has rather set me back on my work here and it has taken a little time to catch up. So here after some delay is the second part on church buildings.

Present Challenges: 4. Church Buildings

Part Two: Easier said than done

‘The Church is the people, not the building.’

How often have I heard this said in my Christian life and ministry? As I have tried to explain in part one of this blog, I think it is more complicated than that and that the relationship between the people, who form the congregation, with the building they meet in is not quite as simple as this saying suggests. It certainly is not simple for me here.

Space is fantastically at a premium in Hong Kong. My parish in Banchory covered an area of about 400 square miles with about 12,000 people. Hong Kong is also an area of 400 square miles, but with a population of 7 million people! Very few people live in houses, most live in apartments in high rise buildings, often what would be regarded as small apartments by people in the UK where I come from. This means that many Churches cannot afford a church building and meet instead in schools or even office space.

Christ Church, then, is extremely fortunate to have a building of its own and a relatively large one at that. It was built in the late 1930s and can seat 250 people comfortably. It is in every way like an English parish church building of the same period, which is not surprising given British influence on Hong Kong. Attached to the main church building is a smaller building with toilets, storage space and a multi-function room. We also have a larger church hall within a newly built block at the school next door. The school has use of this during the week, and the Church uses it only rarely because most of the time the multi-function room at the Church serves most of our needs.

The church building is used for two services on a Sunday, for school services during the week, and whatever weddings or funerals there happen to be. The rest of the time it is locked up. It is quite a landmark on Waterloo Road on the way to the New Territories and to China. The multi-function room is known as the Committee Room and that gives the clue to its main use!

Seventy years old is old for a building in Hong Kong, and it has to be said that the climate is not kind to buildings like ours. There are, of course, always maintenance issues with any building, but maintenance is a particular issue for us. When I arrived the roofs of the buildings attached to the church and to the Vicarage were leaking like sieves in the rainy season. The Church itself, while in generally good condition, also needed some renovation.

What is more the government had made available a considerable amount of money for schools to improve their premises. For us at DPS, the School next to the Church, (about which I have written earlier at some length), this meant demolishing the existing stand alone church hall and building a new 5 storey block containing a new church hall. It was officially opened earlier this year. It was big project taking a few years to complete, but I won’t bore you with the details!

In other words, since being here I have found my time being taken up with buildings to a very significant extent. In addition to the work on the School and church hall, we have re-roofed the flat roofs, replaced all the windows in the church, repaired the external brickwork, repainted the exterior and interior of the church, installed a new pa system as well as all the minor ongoing repairs that have been needed - like replacing the electrics! I have been extremely fortunate in that the Church has given generously to finance this programme of work. Their continuing generosity is a mark of how committed people are to the church and its buildings. We are now about to embark on a major interior refurbishment of the buildings attached to the Church. It is also our hope to install stained glass in the church building itself to enhance its beauty. (Although we are having trouble finding an artist who is able to help!)

I believe in all this and am committed to making it work and to ensuring that the work is done and done well. It does, however, take a great deal of time. And this is where the challenge comes. Firstly, quite simply, work on buildings leaves less time for the work I have always felt most committed to doing, that is, preaching and teaching. Inevitably and rightly, the responsibility for getting the work done and supervising it while it is being done falls to me. The congregation is supportive, but they don’t live here, I do and it really is part of my job as the Vicar.

Secondly, though, it is extremely hard to get people to meet during the week. I think that this is a phenomenon in many churches both in and outside of Hong, especially in congregations where men and women have successful, professional careers.

In an age when often both partners are working, and are often working long hours, by the time they get home from work, see their children, and attend to domestic matters, the last thing they feel like doing is going out to a church meeting – many of which are boring and unnecessary anyway! If I had to spend a couple of hours sitting in traffic to get home after a long and demanding day’s work, I wouldn’t want to go out either.

But this raises the question of how we function as a Church and how those of us with pastoral responsibilities can encourage and help people to grow spiritually. I am concerned that I am spending so much time on the church building and not enough on building the Church. The challenge occurs because many want the building looked after and there for them when they need it, but don’t want much more besides. It suits people to see the Church as the building for if they ensure it is in good condition, then they can feel they have fulfilled a significant part of their Christian responsibility and don’t have to worry about spending additional time, they can ill afford, meeting during the week.

The fact that we do not meet much outside of regular Sunday worship, which is, of necessity, in the church building, and that so much of our time in Committees and the like is spent on discussing building matters, also, inevitably, reinforces the attitude that the building is the Church. Of course, it is more complex than that and I am generalizing horribly. But, I think it is inescapable that the time and emphasis spent on the building strengthens the reluctance for social reasons to meet in small groups during the week! It is a vicious circle: the feeling of being too busy to meet, justified because there is no need to meet anyway.

Please don’t misunderstand me. I, too, love our building and want to see well cared for. I do not want meetings for the sake of them. Many meetings I have to go to as a clergyman I find an unbelievable, even sinful, waste of time. But if a church is to be the body of Christ, a living temple, growing in the love and knowledge of the Lord then it needs fellowship and teaching. How can that teaching and fellowship be provided in a congregation where people have the lifestyles that people in my congregation have and where there is such a strong focus and emphasis on buildings?

It is a real challenge.